Is the Tesla Model 3 really 'Car 2.0'? Maybe not: here's why

Follow John

2017 Tesla Model 3 and 2011 Nissan Leaf, Half Moon Bay, California, Aug 2017  [photo: Scott Forrest]

2017 Tesla Model 3 and 2011 Nissan Leaf, Half Moon Bay, California, Aug 2017 [photo: Scott Forrest]

Enlarge Photo

Like the company's three previous electric cars, the Tesla Model 3 launched into production with a splashy media event during which owners received the keys to their new cars and the company's fans applauded.

Like the Model S and Model X, production is starting at very low rates, with the rate of increase—to 5,000 cars a week by December 31, CEO Elon Musk says—closely watched by analysts, owners, and advocates.

The Model 3 is the culmination of Tesla's August 2006 "Secret Master Plan," which has played out more or less as Musk envisioned it.

DON'T MISS: Which electric car will history view as most important? Poll results

Accordingly, some commentators and owners have taken to suggesting that the Tesla Model 3 is essentially "Car 2.0," the most important car Tesla has made and perhaps the most important car to date of the 21st century.

We think that notion is a mite overblown.

Instead, we'd suggest that the Tesla Model S of 2012 remains the company's most important vehicle, for the earth-shattering impact it had on the entire automotive industry.

2012 Tesla Model S Signature

2012 Tesla Model S Signature

Enlarge Photo

It was the first electric car from a new, hip, tech-forward Silicon Valley auto startup that was simultaneously sleek, sexy, and alluring and also entirely emission-free ... and really fast to boot.

Despite shaky quality in its early years, the Model S deeply startled and frightened the German luxury brands, all of which now have multiple vehicles planned to compete with the Model S and its Model X crossover utility vehicle sibling.

With well over 100,000 Model Ses now delivered globally, that car and its equally important Supercharger network of DC fast-charging stations entirely eradicated the nerdy "golf cart" image of electric cars in a way the Nissan Leaf simply never could.

CHECK OUT: 2017 Tesla Model 3 prices, features, details, specifications from Handover Party

The idea that the Tesla Model 3 may be slightly less than the second coming of [fill in deity or deities of your choice] is eloquently presented by electric-car owner and ChargeWay creator Matt Teske.

In a post on his LinkedIn account, he comments on a rhapsodic opinion piece in The Guardian entitled, "The car is dead, long live the car, thanks to Tesla."

He sums it up quite simply:

Chargeway electric-car charging symbols for Chevrolet Volt, BMW i3, Nissan Leaf, Tesla Model S

Chargeway electric-car charging symbols for Chevrolet Volt, BMW i3, Nissan Leaf, Tesla Model S

Enlarge Photo

The iPhone comparison [in the article] is wrong. The DAY consumers bought an iPhone their experience with communication changed forever.

Model 3 is not that kind of change for cars, but it's a step. It offers the same utility as other cars: Point A to B, with different energy propulsion.

Not until we can buy Level 5 autonomy will the "iPhone car" moment occur.

We couldn't have put it better ourselves.

Consider the comparisons: the Tesla Model S was the first long-range electric car in mass production. Period.

The Chevy Bolt EV, on the other hand, beat the Model 3 by six months as the first 200-mile-plus electric car under $40,000, and base Model 3s at the quoted $35,000 price aren't even in production yet.

2018 Tesla Model 3

2018 Tesla Model 3

Enlarge Photo

There's no question that the Tesla Supercharger network is an enormous, unmatched asset and a brilliantly forward-looking creation that significantly helped Tesla get to where it is today.

But the Model 3's charging rates aren't necessarily as fast as those of the Model S and Model X, and many of its owners will have to pay for DC fast charging above a certain amount of free usage each year.

The Tesla Model 3 continues to have the potential for significant achievement if Tesla can in fact build and deliver in the ambitious volumes it plans.

With 455,000 deposits received, according to a recent update from the company, it should be able to sell the first year's production handily.

But we still think the Model S will remain the more important and innovative vehicle in the eyes of history.

That's our 2 cents; your mileage may vary.

_______________________________________

Follow GreenCarReports on Facebook and Twitter.

 
Follow Us

Take Us With You!

 


 
© 2017 Green Car Reports. All Rights Reserved. Green Car Reports is published by Internet Brands Automotive Group. Stock photography by izmostock. Read our Cookie Policy.