By chance, we ended up with the same car for our weekend review that we'd driven at the media event. Again we felt some powertrain surging and stumbling, with inconsistent brake feel as the car came to a stop and perceptible lurching as the engine turned off.
In fairness, our car was a very early prototype--so early, in fact, that it had no Vehicle Identification Number (VIN) tag visible through the windshield. But we very much hope Honda plans to fine-tune its control software to alleviate these symptoms.
They detract significantly from the driving experience, and seemed--at least to the best of our memory--notably worse than in the last-generation 2009 Civic Hybrid we drove two years ago.
Good handling, road noise
As always, the Civic handling is close to the top of its class, bettered only by the sportier (and much lower volume) Mazda3.
The Civic Hybrid is fun to chuck around corners, and it's easy to place on corners. It always goes exactly where it's pointed under a variety of driving circumstances.
Less pleasant on the road is the high level of wind noise. This is an area where compact cars have made great strides lately, none more so than the remarkably hushed 2011 Chevy Cruze, which may be best-in-class for interior quiet.
The Civic Hybrid uses low-rolling-resistance tires, which may contribute more road noise than the softer, more compliant rubber on other models. But the Civic Hybrid required us to raise our voices slightly at speed on some types of pavement, meaning it's far from a class leader there.
Comfortable, well built
We found the 2012 Civic seats to be comfortable over long distances. They came with well-placed side bolsters and a good range of adjustment--done manually in the hybrid, as usual on fuel-economy models.
2012 Honda Civic launch, New York Auto Show, April 2011Enlarge Photo
In previous comments on the car, we've criticized the hard plastic interiors and an ugly seam that joins two pieces on top of the dashboard. They look cheap, although at least its matte surfaces avoid the ultra-shiny piano black finish that's already a cliche.
But by the end of our four days with the car, we'd gotten used to the dash appearance, though we'd still prefer softer-touch plastics.
Missing convenience items
Some of the minor controls weren't up to par, with rocker switches for temperature and fan speed that are notably inferior to larger rotary knobs found in other compacts--and not easy to read at a glance, either.
Our passenger, in fact, commented that the entire climate-control setup looked at first glance like nothing so much as the face-plate of a 1980s cassette deck.
But the interior was missing some of the amenities found in other compacts: bottle-holders in front and rear door pockets, a rubber mat to prevent mobile phones from sliding on the flat tray ahead of the shift lever, and a rear-seat power outlet.
We do give Honda credit for providing auto-up as well as auto-down on the driver's door. We consider it a safety feature, and it's one of our major irritations in compact-class cost-cutting when it's missing.
Good marks for infotainment
While the iPod integration on the 2012 Civic was intuitive and easy to use, the USB port wouldn't charge unknown devices like the Blackberry we connected. The Bluetooth paired easily and read in directory data quickly.
The navigation system was also intuitive, with good resolution in its smallish screen. And the high-end stereo system produced crisp, clean sound on both the high and low ends of the range.
Hybrid is one high-end Honda
Our Civic Hybrid came with leather seats, a navigation system and XM satellite radio, and several other features that cost extra on most non-hybrid models.
That goes some way to justify its base price of $24,050, but at a sticker price $8,500 over the basic Civic--which starts at $15,805--the payback remains questionable.
As the Union of Concerned Scientists has pointed out, hybrids are usually fitted with high-end features as standard, making it difficult or impossible to get one that's on the lower end of its model range.
Overall, we found the 2012 Honda Civic Hybrid to deliver on its promise of the highest everyday gas mileage in the range.
It had all the traditional Civic virtues: predictable handling, excellent roadholding, and good infotainment features and dashboard infographics.
But the hybrid system wasn't as smooth in operation as we would have liked, especially with a plethora of new full hybrid models entering the market that can move away from a stop on electric power alone.
Competent but costly
As well, the 2012 Civic's interior materials and amenities are now only average in the newly competitive compact sedan class. And its price is steep. While our early car came without a window sticker, we estimate it would run upwards of $25,500.
For that money, you can get a lower-level 2011 Toyota Prius, a midsize five-door hatchback that's a full hybrid and rated by the EPA at 50 mpg combined.
On the other end of the scale, you can get a 2012 Honda Civic HF, rated at 29 mpg city, 41 mpg highway, for $19,455, or several thousand less than the Civic Hybrid.
So it's up to you: What balance will you strike among gas mileage, features, and purchase price? Honda has several alternatives in the new Civic line, and most likely, one of them would hit the right mix for you.
We liked the 2012 Civic Hybrid, but we would have liked it a lot more if it cost $2,000 less.