Michigan socks hybrid owners with new fees—that don't apply to most hybrids (updated)

Follow John

2011 Toyota Prius

2011 Toyota Prius

Enlarge Photo

The state of Michigan, to help pay for road repairs, decided more than a year ago to hit owners of hybrids and electric cars with additional fees starting this January 1—on top of higher registration rates for all cars.

The new fees have been added to the registration bills for hybrids, plug-in hybrid, and battery-electric cars because they don't burn enough gasoline to generate the same state tax revenue as other vehicles.

Hybrid owners are now being hit with the twin increases, noted The Detroit Free Press yesterday, and suffering severe sticker shock as a result.

DON'T MISS: Michigan says Tesla sales ban not unconstitutional, responding to lawsuit

It appears, however, that fees in the bill enacted do not apply to conventional hybrid cars at all—even though the Free Press quotes the owner of two such hybrids being assessed the increased fees.

The paper noted that Shiva Ganganithi, who owns a 2007 Toyota Prius and a 2011 Prius, got hit with registration renewals totaling $339, or $130 more than his previous renewals—a jump that he called "astronomical."

According to the language of the law, a hybrid is “a vehicle that can be propelled at least in part by electrical energy and uses a battery storage system of at least four kilowatt-hours, but is also capable of using gasoline, diesel fuel, or alternative fuel to propel the vehicle."

2007 Toyota Prius

2007 Toyota Prius

Enlarge Photo

That would appear to eliminate the vast majority of Cadillac, Chevrolet, Ford, GMC, Honda, Nissan, and Toyota conventional hybrid vehicles without plugs, whose nickel-metal-hydride or lithium-ion batteries run from 0.6 kwh to 2.1 kwh. 

Hybrid owner Ganganithi's pair of Toyota Priuses, from the 2007 and 2011 model years, have battery capacities of 1.3 kwh and 1.6 kwh respectively.

Neither is remotely close to meeting the 4-kwh minimum that would qualify those cars for the new fees. Only plug-in hybrid powertrains in certain models have battery packs of 4 kwh or more.

UPDATE, Dec 28, 2016: The state of Michigan is now apparently aware that there is an issue with the new fees being charged. Our reader John Briggs received the following note from a Department of State information officer identified only as Chris:

"The Department of State has recently become aware that there may be issues with the way that registration fees are currently being calculated on some hybrid vehicles. These potential issues are currently being investigated. If necessary changes will be made to how registration fees are calculated. It should be noted that individuals renewing before 01/01/17 pay their renewal fees at the 2016 rate, which does not include any additional fees for hybrid or electric vehicles. Individuals can renew up to six months in advance. We apologize for any inconvenience, and thank you for your patience."

Michigan residents with questions about the fees can call 888 SOS-MICH (888-767-6424).

Those include the 2011-2017 Chevrolet Volt, the 2012-2015 Toyota Prius Plug-In Hybrid, the Energi versions of the 2013-2017 Ford Fusion and Ford C-Max, and the new 2017 Toyota Prius Prime, among others.

Which raises the question of whether the state is applying fees to conventional hybrids that the language of the law does not permit.

Ganganithi may have been assessed fees on his pair of Priuses, but they do not qualify as hybrids under the language of the bill enacted—which may have confused conventional hybrids with plug-in hybrids.

2017 Chevrolet Volt

2017 Chevrolet Volt

Enlarge Photo

In November 2015, Michigan governor Rick Snyder signed several bills that collectively made up a $1.2 billion funding package to help repair the state's notoriously rough and pot-holed roads.

The state's registration fees for passenger cars and commercial trucks, which are based on the age and value of the vehicle, rose by roughly 20 percent.

Additional costs apply for special types of license plates and a recreation passport that grants access to state parks, with this year's average cost running about $120 per car, according to a state spokewoman.


 
Follow Us

Take Us With You!

 


 
© 2017 Green Car Reports. All Rights Reserved. Green Car Reports is published by Internet Brands Automotive Group. Stock photography by izmostock. Read our Cookie Policy.