Electric Buses Good For CA? Not If Made By Chinese Company, It Seems

Follow Antony

BYD electric buses

BYD electric buses

Enlarge Photo

We might live in a global economy, but in periods of economic downturn people like to know they're supporting their own country's economy.

That's why some are a little displeased by Long Beach Transit's decision to buy ten elecric buses--made by a Chinese company.

According to The Press-Telegram, the buses were bought under a $12.1 million contract to supply the city with electric public transport--but despite a South Carolina firm being in the running for the contract, it went to BYD (Build Your Dreams) Motors from China.

Marc Gottschalk, chief business development officer and general counsel of Greenville, S.C.-based and General Motors-backed Proterra, sent Long Beach officials a letter questioning why BYD, a company with "a history of overpromising and under-delivering" got the bus contract instead of his own.

"No U.S. content"

Gottschalk says that BYD's bus "has virtually no U.S.-made content, has no U.S. manufacturing (and) has no buses in revenue service in the United States."

He added, "Long Beach Transit has at its disposal the second largest federal grant ever awarded for the deployment of electric buses.

"That it would go to a Chinese company that 'plans' to complete Altoona testing and 'plans' to build a U.S. manufacturing plant and 'plans' to be Buy America-compliant someday in the future and has a record of making false and unreliable public statements - is unfathomable."

It's a sentiment echoed by others, not just those who missed out on contracts. U.S. Rep. Alan Lowenthal (D-Long Beach) weighed in, saying "Although the choice of all electric vehicles is a positive step and should be a point of pride for Long Beach, outsourcing to manufacturing to China raises serious concerns.

"I would hope that the transit board would reconsider purchasing American-made alternatives" he added.

Others are less surprised - "Residents may be appalled at the City of Long Beach decision to contract for buses from BYD, but the City has previously made odd decisions favoring foreign-based automakers," said Long Beach resident and auto writer Michelle Naranjo.

"Those include courting BYD and Korean owned C&T Motors with tax credits to move their North American import headquarters to the former Boeing plant, at the same time it was trying to get Tesla Motors CEO Elon Musk to choose Long Beach as the site to manufacture the Model S electric luxury sport sedan."

BYD responds

Micheal Austin, BYD America vice president, fired a shot back at Gottschalk's criticism of BYD: "This is clearly a smear tactic... I don't think Proterra's general counsel has any credibility in speaking about BYD.

"BYD has far more experience with electric buses than any other competitor, Proterra included, and has far more experience designing buses, shipping buses and building buses than Proterra ever could."

Austin also added that BYD does produce the buses in the U.S, securing American jobs. The Chinese firm is even looking into building a facility in Long Beach itself.

While the technology for electric buses is still at an early stage, the new buses are cleaner than existing natural gas or diesel buses, and could prove cheaper to run.

Long Beach Transit secured the $12.1 million to run a pilot program with the buses, on a small route making stops at the Queen Mary, the Aquarium of the Pacific, the Long Beach Convention and Entertainment Center and Pine Avenue.

The BYD contract is unlikely to change until the Long Beach Transit Board has more information. Two study sessions are being held, to discuss the concerns raised before holding a vote.

At the end of the day, says Board chair Barbara Sullivan, "We wanted to fully understand what was included in the decision and also understand the whole nature of the electric bus phenomenon around the world.... Our decision is to become informed and to make the best solution we can based on what we feel our needs are."


Follow GreenCarReports on Facebook and Twitter.

Follow Us

Comments (6)
  1. We have a lot of electric buses here in Boston. Of course they get their power from over-head lines.

    I assumed they always had to be attached to the lines, but one day I saw the bus lower the structure onto the roof and drive off just like any other bus. I wonder how far they can go and who makes them.

  2. San Francisco also has a good number of similar electric buses.

  3. Maybe we should includes all the Prius bought by the various California State, City and County government in that list of complains...

  4. The Chinese have undercut our pricing on a variety of items killing the industries that used to make up the American middle class. They did this out of corporate greed from this side of the ocean combined with people buying "cheap" instead of American. Some of that was justified, most was not.

    The problem is, it is eroding the middle class to the point where all most people will be able to afford is the cheapest of the merchandise that some foreign operated container ship offloads at our ports. But the upper 2% {wealth wise} of our people should live very well in the ghetto that is known as the USA.

  5. Watch this great video of the Proterra Ecoliner EV on Jay Leno's Garage:


  6. Maybe the LiFePo battery powered BYD buses were offered at lower upfront cost but the lithium titanate powered Proterra buses might have a long term advantage (if that chemistry was offered in the tender). Upfront cost of this battery is higher but since it apparently can do up to 25K deep cycles they would basically last for ever.

    BYD is all about overpromising and underdelivering where electric cars are concerned but it's electric buses business looks more promising with hundreds produced and over one thousand on order from all around the globe.

Commenting is closed for old articles.

Get FREE Dealer Quotes

From dealers near you

Find Green Cars


© 2015 Green Car Reports. All Rights Reserved. Green Car Reports is published by High Gear Media. Send us feedback. Stock photography by izmo, Inc.