Do Hybrids Save Money? Site Helps You Decide

Follow John

2012 Ford Fusion Hybrid

2012 Ford Fusion Hybrid

Enlarge Photo

Hybrid vehicles cost more upfront than comparable gasoline models, but get better fuel economy.

So will you save money in the long run?

To make the comparisons easier and more accurate, the site has launched a new comparison tool that provides a "Years to Payback" number based on the manufacturer's quoted base prices and the EPA gas-mileage ratings for comparable hybrids and non-hybrids.

The important factor here is that the tool attempts to compare models with similar equipment and features--a factor often ignored when comparing a hybrid's price to the least expensive base model of a comparable gasoline vehicle.

As regularly noted--and criticized by the Union of Concerned Scientists and others--hybrid models are usually very well-equipped, with features and equipment as part of their standard price that are optional and cost more on comparable gasoline models.

The new comparison tool can be found by clicking on the "Hybrids Can Save You Money" menu option.

In the first step, the user selects from a list of 18 hybrid models, including both dedicated hybrids (like the various models of the Toyota Prius range) and hybrid models of conventional cars. The list includes mild hybrids like the Honda Civic Hybrid as well as full hybrids like the Ford Fusion Hybrid.

Then the user customizes the calculations by specifying annual miles covered, what percent of those miles are city driving, and the price of fuel to be used for calculations.

'Hybrids Can Save You Money' screenshot from website

'Hybrids Can Save You Money' screenshot from website

Enlarge Photo

Instantly, the calculator shows the difference in list prices and the payback period based on those figures.

Not surprisingly, hybrids pay back quicker if annual miles covered and/or fuel cost rises.

The 2012 Ford Fusion Hybrid offers a good example. Its base price is $29,570, and the calculator compares it not to the lowest-priced Fusion (at $20,705), but the Fusion SEL model that has the mix of features and options closest to those on the hybrid.

The Fusion SEL's base price is $26,220--providing the most realistic, apples-to-apples comparison.

Ah, you say, but I don't really want all those fancy features. I just want a bare-bones hybrid.

That may be true, but that's not the Fusion Hybrid that Ford will sell you. And until the company changes its equipment levels--which we suspect won't happen any time soon--the new calculator attempts to compare cars with equivalent features.

It's worth noting that while Toyota sells a Prius One trim level, essentially a stripped-down model, it's not available to retail buyers. It's solely for fleet purchases. The choice of Prius trim levels for regular consumers starts with the Prius Two.


Follow GreenCarReports on Facebook and Twitter.

Follow Us

Comments (4)
  1. Interesting site.

    So Prius and Prius C are about a 4.5 year payback, by this calculation. Camry XLE and Highlander are about 3 years. After that time, you are better of financially, and of course there are significant environmental benefits to the hybrid.

    But even more interesting is that Buick Lacrosse and Lincoln MKZ are priced the same for hybrid vs non-hybrid. Which should make doing the right thing a no-brainer.

    But I am not going to discuss the Escalade Hybrid or Non-Hybrid. You know what the right answer is with regard to the environment and the Escalade.

  2. "But I am not going to discuss the Escalade Hybrid or Non-Hybrid. You know what the right answer is with regard to the environment and the Escalade."

    Spinning chrome wheels?

  3. Only if they can be used to generate electricity.

  4. In addition to saving fuel, some hybrid vehicles also save much on maintenance. For example, the current generation Prius does not have any utility belt. The timing belt never needs to be replaced(I do not understand why though). Even the brake pads and rotors seem to last forever because of regenerating brake. My 2010 Prius already has 125k miles on odometer, but the brake pads are still in very good shape.

    It seems that the only thing I need to do is changing oil and filter every 10000 miles, plus two air filters every 50000k miles. Really low maintenance car! Oil is kind of expensive though since synthetic oil is required.

Commenting is closed for old articles.

Get FREE Dealer Quotes

From dealers near you

Find Green Cars


© 2015 Green Car Reports. All Rights Reserved. Green Car Reports is published by High Gear Media. Send us feedback. Stock photography by izmo, Inc.