Ethanol Goals Passed By Congress Cannot Be Met: New Study

Follow John

Big square baler harvesting wheat straw for production of cellulosic ethanol

Big square baler harvesting wheat straw for production of cellulosic ethanol

Enlarge Photo

Ethanol has been problematic for several years now.

Promoted as a way for the U.S. to grow its own vehicle fuel, the alcohol was so popular several years ago that Congress passed a Federal Renewable Fuels Standard as part of the 2007 Energy Independence and Security Act.

Now Hart Energy has issued a study saying there is no viable way U.S. fuel producers can comply with the mandates.

Hart expects the law to be changed within a few years.

The 2007 regulations require 36 billion gallons of ethanol to be included in U.S. vehicle fuel by 2022--a volume more than three times the 11.1 billion gallons used in 2010. For 2015, the requirement is 15 billion gallons.

But already the requirements for non-corn ethanol are not being met.

The new study, US & Brazil Ethanol Outlook to 2022, notes that to meet the required volumes of ethanol, the U.S. would have to import substantial quantities from Brazil--quantities that Hart says will not to be available at the times they will be needed.

In fact, Hart says, Brazil won't return to its 2008 ethanol export levels until 2019.

Corn Ethanol Pump

Corn Ethanol Pump

Enlarge Photo

Reasons include under-investment in sugarcane production, high global sugar prices (which make it more attractive to use the cane for sugar rather than fuel), and increasing global demand for ethanol.

At the moment, Hart points out, the U.S. actually exports more ethanol than does Brazil. Together, the two countries produce 80 percent of the world's supply of ethanol.

As a fuel, ethanol turns out to have several drawbacks:

  • The U.S. practice of distilling it from corn yields the lowest productivity per acre of any feedstock
  • Growing crops to serve ethanol feedstock either displaces food crops or requires more land to be farmed
  • The overall carbon footprint of corn-based ethanol is dubious at best
  • Ethanol acts as a solvent and can damage engine parts (especially rubber seals) not designed with it in mind
  • By volume, ethanol has about 30 percent less energy content than gasoline, so fuel economy falls when ethanol is used--meaning more frequent fill-ups

So-called Flex-Fuel vehicles are produced by most U.S. automakers, but the vast majority of them never see a drop of E85 ethanol, a fuel that is available at less than 3,000 of the nation's 25,000 gas stations.

Proposed EPA E15 gasoline pump warning label for ethanol content

Proposed EPA E15 gasoline pump warning label for ethanol content

Enlarge Photo

Additionally, automakers fearful of engine damage fought an EPA proposal to boost allowable ethanol in gasoline from 10 to 15 percent.

Those rules are moving slowly, and it's unclear that gas retailers will make the investments necessary to install new "blender pumps" that mix ethanol and gasoline as requested by customers.

Last December, rather to everyone's surprise, Congress ended ethanol subsidies and removed tariffs on imported ethanol.

Hart Energy will host a webinar on its study findings on Tuesday, May 15, through its Global Biofuels Center.


Follow GreenCarReports on Facebook and Twitter.

Follow Us

Comments (6)
  1. On the positive side, ethanol is now at 10% levels in gasoline displacing foreign imports of oil.

    By the way, the law is intended to force companies to develop cellulosic ethanol. It is time to get that working and the law is intended to create the needed pressure.

  2. Well, it is more like 8-9% since ethanol gets about 10-15% less in MPG. BTW, Canada is our largest oil supplier. Hybrid can easily add 10-20% better mpg than ethanol. Ethanol doesn't really make much economic sense since the ROIC is fairly low, even with celluloisc ehtanol. With that said, Ethanol is cleaner but has shorter shelf lives...

  3. The number I see most often with Ethanol energy content is 30% less energy, so you have a good point.

    The limitations of corn based ethanol is why the law has a cap on it basically at 2011 levels. Future additions the ethanol stream will have to come from other sources, read cellulostic.

  4. FUD... pure and simple... and that's being kind.


  5. @Kid Marc: I welcome facts, studies, or expert opinions that contradict the premise of the report used as the basis for this article. Feel free to provide material that says that in fact the volumes mandated by the Act *are* achievable.

  6. Okay John, but did you ask Hart Energy of their facts? Their opinions to be of experts? Their study to be an actual study?

    Let's try... Mesquite. Grows on 70 million acres of arid lands in the southwest not classified as cropland or farmland. Seeds are 35% sugar. Harvest yields 33 billion gallons/year. Produced without irrigation , fertilizer , and/or annual planting. That's a freebee!

    Jeruselum artichokes yield 550-750 gals/acre

    Sorghum - 3K gals/acre.

    I've already mentioned cattails and kelp, and they don't use any land. :D

    I could give experts, but only EVcast ever bothered to interview them.

    I believe the mesquite alone surpasses 2015 & almost catches 2022.


Commenting is closed for old articles.

Get FREE Dealer Quotes

From dealers near you

Find Green Cars


© 2015 Green Car Reports. All Rights Reserved. Green Car Reports is published by High Gear Media. Send us feedback. Stock photography by izmo, Inc.