Green Car Reports To Name '2012 Best Car To Buy' Next Week

Follow John

Best Car To Buy?

Best Car To Buy?

Enlarge Photo
'Tis the season for 'car of the year' awards, and we're right there with the rest of the media.

Next Monday, we'll announce the winner of our second annual Green Car Reports "Best Car to Buy" Award winner for the 2012 model year. At the same time, our sister sites--MotorAuthority and TheCarConnection--will announce their winners as well.

And we've set up a special page, Best Car To Buy 2012, that lets you scan all the stories we've written about the candidates and the award. It includes the 2011 contenders and last year's winner, the 2011 Nissan Leaf--the first battery electric vehicle to be sold in volume in the U.S. in many, many decades.

So why have we joined the awards parade?

While we write a lot about future vehicles, many of our readers seek practical information about which cars not only save gasoline but also reduce their impact on the environment.

To help answer that question, last year we rolled out a new "Green Rating" for every 2011 car we reviewed on our comprehensive reviews site And we're continuing that practice for 2012.

But a single winner here on Green Car Reports offers many benefits, including the call to get car buyers focused on why that particular model was our Best Car To Buy for its year.

Green Car Reports 2012 Best Car To Buy award

Green Car Reports 2012 Best Car To Buy award

Enlarge Photo

With that, here are the rules, virtually identical to those we published last year:

The Rules

The selection process begins with all new vehicles introduced or significantly updated for the 2012 model year. To be eligible, vehicles also must be available for purchase by April 2012. This eliminates few contenders, while bringing you the best information as soon as possible.

NOTE: We goofed, and in the original version of this article, forgot to update our price limit to $60,000--now corrected--which as one commenter pointed out, would make the Infiniti M35h ineligible. We apologize.

We apply a $60,000 $50,000 base-price cap on entries, to focus on mass-market vehicles and eliminate ultra-luxury green machines that sell in such small numbers that their cumulative impact is negligible. We rank the contenders by the numeric scores found on TheCarConnection's full vehicle reviews.

Finally, we choose the greenest new vehicle(s) from the top of the rankings, based largely on the ratings. Ties and qualitative issues are then discussed by High Gear Media editors who weigh other factors, including market impact, consumer significance, and lifetime environmental impact.

The nominees for GCR's Best Car to Buy 2012 are:

We'll highlight each of these cars in its own story during the course of this week.


Follow GreenCarReports on Facebook and Twitter.

Follow Us

Comments (6)
  1. Are the eAssist hybrids from GM not improved enough over the previous BAS hybrids to qualify?

  2. What is the wisdom of only considering "new" or "updated" cars?

    Doesn't the name "Best Car to Buy" imply that you are giving the award to the best car. In fact your rules imply that you are not choosing the "Best car" but simply the "best car" that happened to be introduced in 2012.

    But I guess the media must always focus on "new" rather than things that are already working well.

  3. @John: Good question, but it's fairly standard among automotive awards to restrict the choice only to vehicles that are either all-new or substantially improved in the year the award is for. Among other things, it diversifies the pool of candidates. Otherwise, in our case, the most efficient plug-in car would win every time--and not only is that boring, but it doesn't help those people who simply won't or can't buy a plug-in car. So ideally we'll have different types of vehicles as winners over several years.

  4. Thanks for the thoughful explaination.

    I still have a problem with the name. Seems like this should be "Best New Car" rather than "Best Car To Buy".

  5. Is it just me, of does the question mark vehicle look awesome. Bet it would be low drag.

  6. Agreed! Get rid of the visibility problem and I just might place a deposit...

Commenting is closed for old articles.

Get FREE Dealer Quotes

From dealers near you

Find Green Cars


© 2015 Green Car Reports. All Rights Reserved. Green Car Reports is published by High Gear Media. Send us feedback. Stock photography by izmo, Inc.