2012 Toyota Prius Plug-in Hybrid: Everything to Everyone?

Follow Nikki

The iconic Toyota Prius was the car which started the hybrid revolution. Offering fuel economy that very few other gasoline cars could hope to achieve, it has been loved by politicians, movie stars and wannabe greenies for over ten years.  

Although Toyota improved its hybrid drivetrain for the 2010-11 Toyota Prius to give even better gas mileage, the aging platform - soon to be a brand in its own right - is struggling to defend its green image against eco newcomers like the 2011 Nissan Leaf and 2011 Chevrolet Volt. 

Toyota’s solution? Turn the popular Prius into a plug-in hybrid, capable of around 13 miles powered entirely by electricity alone - and sell it as the ultimate all-round eco-car. 

Our John Voelcker got some time behind the wheel of a prototype of the 2012 Toyota Prius Plug-in Hybrid back in April last year, followed by a longer 424 mile thanksgiving trek. Even our Deputy Editor Bengt Halverson, normally found at the wheel of larger, less environmentally friendly cars has had some time with one, leading to ask if by the numbers. would it would work for you?

But while we know the 2012 Toyota Prius Plug-in Hybrid is great -- if a little sluggish -- around town in all-electric mode, we wanted to see how it would fare in the real-world test of a family holiday. 

1,400 miles, two adults, two kids, a whole lot of luggage. And a dog. 

Playing Tetris with your dog

The first challenge on the week-long holiday was finding a place to put everything and everyone. Thanks to its larger 4 kilowatt-hour battery pack, the 2012 Toyota Prius Plug-in Hybrid doesn’t have the same under-load-bay storage found in its non plug-in sibling. In addition, the load-bay floor is approximately 1 inch higher, further restricting the storage space available. 

Fortunately for us, hours of playing Tetris and paying attention in geometry class paid off. Kids, dog and adults were accommodated. The Prius’ fifth seat helped greatly in our task, allowing us to use one of the rear seats to house a large suitcase while retaining somewhere for both children to sit in their booster seats. 

Admittedly, a roof rack would have given more space inside at the detriment of fuel economy, but given the lack of roof bars, we opted for another solution: putting the small amount of excess luggage in the 2009 Toyota Prius our friends were driving. 

A point of note before we move on: Toyota has told us that the production version of the 2012 Prius Plug-in Hybrid will feature a lithium-ion rather than nickel-metal-hydride battery pack, meaning the luggage space will be closer to that available in the standard 2012 Prius. 

Better fuel economy than the Volt on long-distance trips

While the 2012 Toyota Prius Plug-in Hybrid doesn’t have the all-electric range of its closest rival - the 2012 Chevrolet Volt - it does boast a range of around 550 miles on a full tank of gasoline and a fully charged battery pack. 

On the way to our destination, we were able to charge after around 280 miles while having a meal at the first freeway rest stop in England to have an electric car charging station, enabling the fuel economy to hover around 66 mpg for the first day. 

Interestingly, that represents a better fuel economy than the 60 mpg given by the EPA to the 2011 Chevrolet Volt for a combined cycle and a much improved economy over the Volt’s official EPA rating of 37 mpg once its battery pack has been depleted. 

In other words, on longer trips, the 2012 Prius Plug-in Hybrid wins hands down.

Less so on mid-distance trips

But the advantages the 2012 Plug-in Prius has over the 2011 Chevrolet Volt  disappears when doing mid-range trips of between 30 and 80 miles, as we soon found out.

In rural Scotland, we found very few places to plug in and recharge the Prius’ battery pack. As a consequence, trips to local tourist spots were made on just one charge of the battery pack per day. 

And as soon as our battery pack was empty, we were back to gasoline operation. 

Minimal range needn’t be a problem though

We’ve got to admit that the 2012 Toyota Prius Plug-in Hybrid has an absolutely lousy all-electric range on paper. It’s not much better in real life. But with careful driving, we were able to get as many as 20 miles of all-electric driving, and even managed a mountain climb or two in all-electric mode. 

So it can’t go very far in all-electric mode. But if you live and work in the same area or have access to regular charging that might not be so much of an issue. And we’re guessing that when it launches, Toyota will make the Prius Plug-in Hybrid as easy (if not easier) to get as the 2012 Nissan Leaf or 2012 Chevrolet Volt. 

Follow Us

Comments (6)
  1. If Toyota is worried about its green image it shouldn't bother. Their Pirus already is greener than the Chevy Volt or Nissan Leaf. Way greener. For typical drivers over twice as green as electric. Making it a plug-in increases its carbon emissions.

  2. My mistake - Prius greener when compared against EV using national average electricity (1.2 pounds per kilowatthour) Prius : 15 pounds CO2 per 50 miles,
    EV like Volt or Leaf, will require 10kWhrs + 2.5 kWhrs loss due to battery, plus 1 due to transmission losses = 13.5 kWhrs, which produces 1.2 X 13.5 = 16.2 pounds of carbon. Using coal generated power = 27 pounds CO2 used by EV per 50 miles.

  3. Ramon - You've made another mistake. Burning coal is not cool but how do you think that gallon of gas got extracted, refined, and transported to the local gas station? Normal people know these basics by now, so it's time to STFU.

  4. DO we know what the price of the Plug-in-Prius is? I asked in the UK and was told "about 28 to 30 thousand" [pounds]. That was 2 days before GM announced the price of the Volt and Ampera here - which is £29,000.

    If the Plug-in-Prius only really wins out on long distance drives with 63 mpg (which I presume is imperial mpg, equating to 52 US mpg) then surely the natural competition are diesels?

  5. By the way, I worked through the numbers for if I'd done my last year's driving in a Volt/Ampera: 1129 mpg.

  6. David,

    Firstly, this is a U.S. site, so all comparisions are with U.S. based vehicles and use U.S. fuel figures. So 63 mpg is a U.S. figure, equating around 75.6 imperial mpg.

    Secondly, we made it very clear that we're talking longer distance driving in the real world, plugging in regularly for short trips but chosing gasoline for the longer trips.

    How does your 1129 mpg (940 U.S?) get made up?

Commenting is closed for old articles.

Get FREE Dealer Quotes

From dealers near you

Find Green Cars


© 2015 Green Car Reports. All Rights Reserved. Green Car Reports is published by High Gear Media. Send us feedback. Stock photography by izmo, Inc.